Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese Recipe

Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese Recipe – CBRL Menu
⚡ Quick answerThis Cracker Barrel mac and cheese recipe uses elbow macaroni, Colby and sharp cheddar, milk, eggs and butter, baked at 350°F for 30 minutes for the same creamy, set texture as the restaurant side.
  • Serves 8
  • Baked, custard-style mac
  • Shred your own cheese

My experience: Mac and cheese is serious business in my family, and this copycat earns its place at our table — creamy, properly cheesy, with that baked top. I have made it for holidays and plain Tuesdays alike; the stovetop-to-oven method below is my keeper.

Cracker Barrel Mac and Cheese Recipe: Ingredients

IngredientAmount
Elbow macaroni1 lb
Colby cheese, shredded2 cups
Sharp cheddar, shredded2 cups
Whole milk2 cups
Eggs2
Butter4 tbsp
Salt1 tsp
Dry mustard (optional)½ tsp

Step-by-Step Instructions

  1. Cook macaroni 2 minutes less than the package says; drain.
  2. Toss hot pasta with butter.
  3. Whisk milk, eggs, salt and mustard.
  4. Layer pasta and most of the cheese in a buttered 9×13 dish; pour the milk mix over.
  5. Top with remaining cheese.
  6. Bake at 350°F for 30 minutes; rest 10 minutes.
“Shred your own cheese. Pre-shredded = grainy mac. Every time.”
🐦 Tweet this

Why Colby Cheese?

Colby melts smoothly and keeps the mac creamy, while sharp cheddar gives the flavor. Pre-shredded cheese has anti-caking starch that can make it grainy.

Restaurant Side Facts

At the restaurant, Mac n’ Cheese is a $3.09 side with about 270 calories – read more about Cracker Barrel mac n cheese.

🧑‍🍳 Copycat success in 4 steps
🛒Shop
Full-fat dairy & real butter
🥣Mix
Just until combined
🔥Bake/cook
Watch the color, not only the clock
⏱️Rest
5–10 min before serving

Upgrades

  • Bacon mac: stir in 6 slices crumbled bacon
  • Crunchy top: buttery cracker crumbs
  • Spicy: a pinch of cayenne
“Colby + sharp cheddar: creamy meets bold. That’s the Cracker Barrel mac combo.”
🐦 Tweet this

Storing and Reheating Mac and Cheese

StorageHow longReheat
Fridge (airtight)3–4 daysOven 350°F until hot, or microwave covered
FreezerUp to 3 monthsThaw overnight, then reheat in the oven
Make aheadAssemble 1 day earlyAdd 5–10 minutes baking time from cold

Homemade vs Restaurant

Homemade copycatAt Cracker Barrel
CostUsually cheaper per serving (≈ estimate)Menu price + tip
Time30–90 minutesReady in minutes
ControlAdjust salt, sugar, fatFixed recipe
TasteVery close with the right ingredientsThe original

Want the real thing without cooking? Order Cracker Barrel To Go or try our other Cracker Barrel copycat recipes.

Equipment for Mac and Cheese

  • Mixing bowls and a whisk
  • Measuring cups and spoons
  • Baking dish, skillet or sheet pan (see recipe)
  • Instant-read thermometer for meats
  • Foil or a lid for reheating

Scaling the Recipe

ServingsMultiply ingredients byBake/cook time
Half batch× 0.5Check 5–10 minutes early
Standard× 1As written
Double× 2Use two pans; add 5–10 minutes
Holiday crowd (×3)× 3Bake in batches

Make It Lighter

  • Use reduced-fat cheese or milk for half the amount
  • Swap some butter for olive oil where it melts in
  • Add extra vegetables to casseroles
  • Serve smaller portions with a big green side

How to Serve It Like Cracker Barrel

Serve family-style with two country sides and warm biscuits or corn muffins. For a full menu at home, pair it with country green beans, sweet carrots and buttermilk biscuits.

Allergens and Dietary Notes

Cracker Barrel kitchens use shared fryers and grills, and many dishes contain milk, wheat, eggs or pork. If you have an allergy, tell your server before ordering and check the official allergen guide.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Overmixing the batter or dough, which makes it tough
  • Swapping full-fat dairy for low-fat – the texture changes
  • Not tasting for salt at the end
  • Serving straight from the oven instead of letting it rest a few minutes

How We Check Prices and Facts

Prices on this page come from a Nashville-area Cracker Barrel menu checked in October 2026, and calories come from Cracker Barrel’s published nutrition information where available. We re-check our pages every month, but prices differ slightly by state and seasonal items change, so confirm in the app or with your store. Spotted something out of date? Email [email protected].

Frequently Asked Questions

What cheese does Cracker Barrel use in mac and cheese?

A copycat uses Colby and sharp cheddar for creaminess and flavor.

Is Cracker Barrel mac and cheese baked?

It’s a creamy, set-style mac; baking with eggs recreates that texture.

Can I make it ahead?

Assemble, refrigerate up to a day and bake 40 minutes from cold.

How do I reheat mac and cheese?

Add a splash of milk and warm covered at 325°F.

Final Word

This baked Cracker Barrel mac and cheese recipe is the side kids and grown-ups fight over – make a double batch.

Related Guides

C
Written by Capri – food writer at CBRL Menu who has eaten at Cracker Barrel stores across the South and tracks menu prices, calories and policy changes every month. Questions or corrections: [email protected]

CBRL Menu is an independent guide and is not affiliated with Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Inc. Prices and calories can change; check with your local store.

Similar Posts